These are the only cat treats that my wonderful Angel of a vet sells in her office and recommends.
Picked up a jar and the minute I opened them all 6 cats, one of whom is pretty arthritic, came a running

Almost lost my finger tips!!!

I also took and placed some of the powder that settles at the bottom of the jar on their food and we had sunshine plates. My gang eats no dry at all as I have one cat newly diagnosed with Interstitial Cystitis. I have sprinkled some over their NV Instinct canned and some over their Wellness canned and boy are they happy.
One thing though. Once you open the little jug, make sure you refrigerate it. The package says to do that, But I almost missed it. I am planning to try the Beef flavor too.