Davis, I am not angry as I know who I am and my intent.  I am in no position to question anyone else as to intent. One particularly mean entry right after my initial one was later removed. I was ready to "dump" this site at that point. Then I decided to post a strong response instead. Others may have dropped the site. My only point is that it would be a shame to lose the original purpose by infighting and unfounded accusations or attacks.
I understand why some are so angry. We are lucky here as the dogs are healthy and their foods, at least at this time, are "safe". However, I now find that premium companies I have trusted and  that made claims of processing all their products were in fact not telling the truth. I also trusted Whole Dog Journal and now know they did a less than thorough job when making up their yearly lists. I guess the teacher in me just wants this site to remain positive and helpful to all who visit.
Thanks for taking the time to respond to me.

At this point I am totally confused as to all the contradictions going on at this site.    I joined to find out what was going on with pet foods in general, to learn people's experiences with feeding their pets from the options available, any nutritional info QUALIFIED individuals might offer and I have no problem with manufacturer's talking about their foods if they identify themselves as part of the company and if they REFRAIN from downgrading other manufacturers. Each time I post I speak for me only. What I am finding is:
I have been attacked as a "shill" for a particular pet food when all I wanted to do was help by offering something I was happy with after much research on my own. Other people have been included and have even been accused of all "sounding alike". Hardly so, and as a teacher with a background in English I can refute that with some expertise. I hear people offering nutritional advice when it is obvious they do not know what they are talking about instead of sticking to the anecdotal and I have heard from some very sincere, helpful and knowledgeable people such as JayJay. Please let's keep things on a level where everyone benefits and no one is insulted. Otherwise the real purpose of this wonderful site will be lost. I will end by commending Theresa for this and her food lists on Petsitusa. She is a genius and has the most readable and user friendly sites I have found.  A+ Theresa.
PS I followed Whole Dog Journal's pet food list for years. After what I have learned in the last month I will no longer even renew my subscription and  I did let them know why. Not even the courtesy of a reply from them.

I have been following everyone's posts for a while now and one thing concerns me. People are giving information on ingredients used, nutritional information, and other information out that would require a professional background. If someone has an expertise in animal nutrition, nutrition, veterinary medicine, research chemistry, FDA or any related field I would love to know it and hear what you have to say in regard to the nutrition, ingredients or make up of various pet foods but please identify yourself by stating your background.  If not it would be better if people stuck to their personal experiences with a given food and stayed away from the scientific analysis. I have seen some instances of possibly serious misinformation here and on some of the other blogs. It helps no one if misinformation is spread. I am a teacher and can tell you what I like or don't and why. I can forward you to websites where information can be found. I CAN NOT analyze pet foods nor should I try.
"A little knowledge is a dangerous thing." Have a great weekend everyone. It is gorgeous here at the Jersey shore today!

I wonder how many of these "sophisticated" thinkers have even bothered to contact the Kumpi folks?  I have read their moaning and complaining for several weeks now about how badly pet food manufacturers have treated people, how they get no responses or only generic responses, how they have been jumping from one food to another (very bad for kitty and dogs digestive systems by the way) and when a handful of people are trying to help them out by giving info on a food that they are pleased with they deem themselves "too sophisticated" to even make a phone call to the one company that will speak to them, answer all questions, explain what is in the food, etc.
I contacted Kumpi because of the silliness on the Petsitusa blog. Someone with knowledge tried to offer info then, not sell food, and they attacked her. Guess I have these "sophisticated" folk to thank as that piqued my curiosity or I might never have paid attention to her food. At risk of having these companies attacked also I will say that I would feel safe with Flint River, Back to Basics and was always happy with Wysong too.
Well you can't help those who will not help themselves but as a "Jerseyite" myself I dare some of you to actually call Evy Serpa and find out why Kumpi has supporters.

  So sorry to see an atitude like yours on a site like this. I for one have been following petsitusa (the easiest site to follow Theresa),Itchmo,and now this list for about a month. I have fed my dogs Wysong for years but decided shortly before the scare that it was time to consider a switch. I took my time and checked out virtually every high end company on Theresa's list. I emailed several including Kumpi and Evy Serpa got back to me in a couple of hours. She sent literature to me by email and in the mail. I checked out where Kumpi is made and the processor  makes human food. Everything made sense to me and some incorrect beliefs I had were corrected. She has a very professional manner and a willingness to share. My dogs have been on Kumpi Adult for a week now and seem to like it just fine. Since they are healthy, well fed and two are AKC champions I am not looking for more than a good, healthy and safe food. As a retired teacher with 34 years in a classroom I can assure you I do not do things without careful study. Evy Serpa of Kumpi is a born teacher whether she knows it or not. I had never heard of her or her food a month ago. I have NO REASON to doubt the others who have recommended her dog/cat food. Perhaps it is just a superior company. Sorry for being so wordy but I see absolutely nothing helpful in an attitude like the  one above. WELL NOW YOU HAVE HEARD FROM ME!!! Why don't you give her a call.

Researched Kumpi and got quick email responses to all questions. Ordered on line and  had delivery (across country) in a few days.

After studying many websites and dog foods I have switched to Kumpi. My dogs seem to like it and I am amzed at the service you get from owner Evy Serpa. It makes sense to me. I have switched from Wysong Maintenance which has less meat than Kumpi.