I switched my cats from Science Diet when the recall first hit, and I tried a number of premium brands before landing on Eagle Pack Holistic, which is one of only two brands of canned food that they'll eat consistently. (The other is Innova/Evo.) I wanted to switch them to Felidae, because it's one of the few with a good ingredient list that isn't made at Menu, but they're fussy about it--some days they'll eat it, but not always. And Felidae seems to have significant differences in quality from batch to batch.

But they loved all but one of the Eagle Pack flavors right away, and they also like the dry, which they get as an occasional treat. We've had no digestive issues as a result of the switch, and I think they've even lost a little bit of weight. Their coats seem extra shiny too. Overall, I'm very pleased with the brand.