My e-mail was bounced back as "mailbox full" when I sent it asking where the canned was made. So, I called again today and got thru. The person was very vaque and said it was made by "one of their partners" in the US. I said I couldn't believe he didn't know which one as there apparently aren't that many. I said it was clearly stated that the Blue Seal was made at Menu foods, but the website conveniently doesn't say where By Natures is made. I said a lot of people are wanting to know this before they order and he said that their food is flying off the shelves even without people knowing that info. SO, beware buyers. It seems very fishy that he couldn't tell me who makes their canned By Natures products. Please stop buying this food until they disclose that info, otherwise, they apparently think hiding the information is working just fine!!!